h1

Healing meters – Do numbers really not matter?

10/31/2009

I’ve been reading a whole lot more healing blogs recently, specifically the answers to Jessabelle’s non-meme and there’s a pattern that I’ve noticed of some disparaging remarks being made in regards to healing meters.  Do I think we should all be watching our numbers like hawks?  Heck no.  But I wanted to touch on why numbers aren’t as bad as people make out.  So let’s have a conversation about Healing Per Second (HPS), Healing Per Mana (HPM), Healing Per Cast Time (HPCT) and Healing Per Encounter (HPC)!

- Trivial content vs. progression content -

Let’s face it, everyone has encounters that our raiding groups find incredibly easy.  For some it might be, say, something along the lines of Sarth+0 that they find easy or for others it might be ToC.  Whatever it is, fights that you out skill, over-gear, and frankly out heal are just not very good times to look at your healing numbers in any serious fashion.  The less you have to work at keeping people alive, the less you have to care about how well you’re doing.  (Makes sense right?)  Those are the times to relax, maybe do a little DPSing around your heals or goof off by playing the “pad the meters” game.  If the only content you are running is stuff that your raiding group finds easy, then you pretty much never have to worry about anything other than making sure you keep people up.  It isn’t until you’re doing encounters that pushes you that you have to worry about how well you’re really doing.

- Healing isn’t a competition with other people, just yourself -

DPS was my raiding role for quite a while and it wasn’t until I’d really gotten a handle on the healing game that I realized how much I didn’t like DPSing at all.  For one it was boring and for two I hated having to compete with the other DPSers.  Healing doesn’t have that; in fact, it has the opposite!  Healers need to work together closely to keep people alive and have everything move smoothly.  It’s a team sport all the way.

There is a general feeling that runs among the healing crowd that healing meters work against that feeling of team-play, but I’m going to argue against that.  If anything, I think being able to see what your other healers are doing -promotes- good teamwork.  We can all see what everyone is doing, so we’re more aware of each other.  It also fosters personal responsibility, in that if you aren’t pulling your weight and you’re making the jobs of the other 5 people harder, they will know about it.  Being able to see the meters is also a learning tool for the team.  “Hey look,” the Holy priest says, “Tree druid is getting most of her heals from Rejuv.  Teach me, oh leafy one, the reasons behind this.”  Knowing more about each other’s spells and abilities makes for a smoother, more cohesive healing structure.

Can healing meters make for some competition?  Of course.  Is that Recount’s fault?  Heck no.  If you do have other healers or raid leadership looking at your Recount numbers in disapproval, use those numbers to show them what you’re doing and why.  Bad assignments, too many healers for content and other factors influence your standing on the meters, so be sure to bring those issues up with raid leadership.  However, if you -are- having issues pulling your weight on the healing team and making it harder for everyone else to do their jobs, let Recount be a tool to fixing that.  To quote Isaac Asimov, “If knowledge can create problems, it is not through ignorance that we can solve them.”

- A tool is there to be used –

Let’s touch on what Recount/World of Logs is actually giving you insight into.  (For the record, Recount isn’t as good at helping you see what’s going on with your healing, but since you can’t look at your group’s WoL -during- attempts, it can help solve problems on the fly.)

HPS (healing per second):  Our burst healing metric.  This is an important one to keep an eye on during those fights where you have people going from 100% to dead in 3 seconds.  Just like DPS meters, if you’re just looking at Recount’s raw numbers, it’ll be giving you an average HPS for the fight, which is less accurate than narrowing the timeframe.  Increasing spellpower is the main way to increase this number along with haste.

HPCT (healing per cast time):  Very similar to HPS and generally more useful (and harder) to know.  You know those fights where everyone is just taking extreme amounts of damage at an alarming rate?  This is the one to look at, especially for raid healers.  Think of it as the Renew to HPS’s Flash Heal.  Haste is very important for this, especially reaching that GCD soft-cap.  After that, it’s all about spellpower.

HPM (healing per mana):  Ah, mana efficiency.  We all know the importance of having enough mana to heal an entire fight, but this is one that does indeed have a “soft-cap” of sorts, in that it stops being as important as throughput after a while.  A general rule of thumb is to worry about HPM during the lulls most fights have and then let it fall away when the difficult parts come up.  If you end a fight with just a teeny bit of mana left and all cooldowns blown, you’ve found the “sweetspot” for mana efficiency.

HPE (healing per encounter/overall healing):  This is your final number at the end of a fight, what I like to call The Big One.  What can you learn by looking at it?  Not terribly much other than where you stand compared to the other healers.  Yes, I know that healers hate having that competitive thing going on, but it is important to be able to see if you’re falling way behind everyone else.

Overheal:  Ah, the thing we all hate and can’t get away from.  I recently solo-healed a Beasts-10 harmode (the other healer died right off the bat) and I had the lowest overheal to HPS ratio I’ve ever had.  LOL  Let’s face it, you -will- overheal.  Some classes will overheal a lot more than others and some spells will overheal a lot more than others.  It’s important to know those distinctions and to work to minimize the overheal you -can- control.

Effective healing:  This pretty much boils down to HPE – overheal = effective healing.  I actually find this to be less of a useful number than the others.  If you have a person or two in the group that has very low effective healing, that probably means that you have too many healers for the encounter.  Looking at the effective healing per spell can be useful, however, in determining the best spell for specific encounter mechanics.

Spells cast:  I love this one, although Recount doesn’t do nearly as well on the breakdown as World of Logs.  How many times did you cast X spell and on who?  This is a great, great tool for analyzing healing skill and class knowledge.  (ie. if your Disc priest is casting Powerword: Shield only 5 times in a fight, there are issues)  Sometimes all it takes is looking at your spells cast to immediately see a place you can improve.

Active time:  There are two versions of this.  One is active time per spell and the other is active time per healer.  Per spell you can consider most useful for tracking HoT and buff uptime.  This is especially important to look at when it comes to tank healers.  Tanks should have a very, very high uptime on all of class-related healing abilities.  (ie. Inspiration, Sacred Shield, Earth Shield, Rejuv, etc.)  Per healer means how much of the encounter that healer was doing -something- other than stand around.  This is very much factor dependant on fight mechanics (long pauses between phases) and healing assignments (tank healer vs raid healer).  However, if a person is active a whole lot less than their teammates, that’s a big red flag.

- Putting it all together –

When people say that “numbers don’t matter,” I’m not sure they’re taking a look at the bigger picture.  The numbers -do- matter in context and I think it’s a matter of too many people being judged on raw HPS and HPE that makes healers rebel so completely.  Let’s face it, I’ve seen plenty of bosses where our healing output was a serious consideration.  The first time I healed Patchwerk, it was all about HPE numbers being high enough to keep the tanks up.  General Vezax needs a very, very careful watch on the team’s HPM.  Mimiron has some fun phases where first it is all about HPS and then all about HPCT, especially for druids and priests.

These are all things that a good healing lead needs to consider when setting up assignments and in couching her/his team towards victory.  We all know that it royally sucks when a boss kill just won’t come because the healers can’t keep people alive.  Looking at the logs can help you see where, exactly, you’re lacking and give you ideas on how to fix it.  Yes, it sucks to have people studying you to see where you’re weakest, but if you don’t know where you can improve, you -won’t- improve.

Looking at the big healing picture, healing meters are just one piece of the whole.  There’s a whole lot they can tell you and a whole lot they can help you make educated guesses on, but they’re just a tool.  Think of Recount/WoL as an MRI scan.  Information galore can be gleaned from it, but you aren’t going to make all your medical decisions solely on it.  Use the numbers to improve, use them to open up communication with your healing teammates and your raid leadership.  Raiding is a group effort, so let’s all do our very best out on that field.

About these ads

14 comments

  1. I can’t thank you enough for posting that! I’ll definitely show your post to my fellow raiders when the topic comes up. You do a good job of breaking down and explaining the different points to consider.

    When people say that they hate healing meters, what they usually mean is they hate being judged and ranked exclusively on HPS and effective heals. I find a lot of non-healers don’t understand how to read heal meters and try to look at them as they would dps meters.

    I had a dpser once tell me : “I tried healing once. I’m really good at it, I was first on the healing meter!” I asked him if he was the only healer. Obviously, if you’re first on effective heals, you’re doing something right, but there’s a lot more to the picture!


    • No problem! I personally love healing meters, so I always try to make it very clear to my healing team what I’m looking at and why. I’ll admit that I don’t remember ever running into someone who judged purely on healing meters, but I’m sure they exist. We aren’t DPS, darn it, we don’t have set rotations! LOL


  2. I don’t hate the meters. I think they’re useful, but I hate when someone who’s healing over my hots wants to point out they did more healing and I do overhealing. Yeah… thanks person.
    No one is dying- healers are doing their job. :)
    But they are great for pinpointing a flaw, or how to improve something. I know I use some spells more than others sometimes and it helps to have that pointed out.
    They make everything better- Overall. But you always have one or two jerks that don’t understand how to read it.


    • I’ll admit, I’ve never followed the “if no one dies, yay” thought pattern, mostly because it’s possible for a couple really stellar healers to make up for some lack-luster healers in a pinch. It’s not fair to the good healers to have to carry the non-stellar healer, IMO. Which is why I’m eternally sorting through meters, reading strats and analyzing things. LOL I totally get what you’re saying about HoTs being overridden by fast heals from other people, but if that’s really a big issue, then you’re bringing too many healers or the fight is too easy to get any good meter information from, anyway. :)


  3. Sigh, Moar, I think i have a healer-crush on you. This is probably one of the most informative “all healers need to read this or gtfo” posts I’ve seen in a long time. I kinda want to print it out and tape it next to my monitor for when I’m trying to evaluate my healers. Does that make me insane? :::ponders:::

    MoarHPS – Helping Math-tards understand the basics since 2009.


    • Aw…. LOL Thanks, hon!


  4. Does your blog have an RSS subscription link somewhere? I can’t seem to find it but I want to add it to my reader.


    • Oh, hrm, I don’t know how to add one! :x I’ll do a bit of searching and see if I can figure it out!


      • Codi, try feedburner.com, that’s what I use!


  5. good stuff, very ice and informative. i shared it to my fellow guild members as well. i added your site as one of my fave blog list as well. thanks hon!


    • gah i just woke up and i mispelled “very ice” instead of very nice” ahaha sorry about that! =)


  6. YES! Dont forget WoL and MOW scoreboards/ranking too.

    Ratings are best used for busting myths and learning new tricks.

    For instance, disc on the raid is surprisingly effective for fights with random spiky raid damage — like jarraxus and FC. Check it http://www.wowmeteronline.com/rank/clazz/ehps/all/8/6/3

    The numbers here = an evidence based argument against the old claim that holy > disc on raid.


    • *MOW = WMO (Wow meters online) typo

      – adorno


  7. This topic was enough to motivation me to get a blog rolling. I reference your blog in the first post, check it out and lend some feedback if you get the chance.

    http://one-priests-opinion.blogspot.com/2009/12/one-priests-opinion.html

    Happy blogging,

    -Ad



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: